This article contains affiliate links. If you book or buy through them, Travel Life may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

Four years after our silver wedding anniversary at Merchants Manor, we went back to Falmouth and stayed one floor up. Which is better? We still can’t decide.

As we checked out of Merchants Manor this month, the manager asked a simple question. Which did we prefer: the Landlubber, where we’d stayed in 2022, or the Lookout, directly above it, where we’d just spent the weekend?

We honestly couldn’t say. The Landlubber has those gorgeous green-tiled bathrooms. The Lookout has the sea view. It really is a flip of a coin.

The staircase and stained-glass window at Merchants Manor

The house

Merchants Manor stands on the hill above Falmouth, a big white house among palms and subtropical planting. It was built in 1913 for the Carne family, merchants and brewers who are credited with developing the screw-cap bottle. A gravel drive brings you to a wide entrance hall, and a staircase climbs past a beautiful old stained-glass window.

The lounge and log fire at Merchants Manor

To the left is the lounge, where the log fire was lit the whole time we were there. Beyond it is the breakfast room, with a raised section that makes the most of the view. Old black-and-white photographs of Falmouth line the corridors alongside some tasteful art. The floors are a mix of tiles and carpet in the public rooms and warm wood in the apartments. It’s a cosy, easy-going place, the kind of hotel where you put your feet up rather than sit up straight.

Living room and kitchen in the Lookout suite

The Lookout

The Lookout is a two-bedroom apartment with a rustic feel: reclaimed timber walls, warm wood floors and good-quality fabrics and fittings that make it feel homely. Each bedroom has its own bathroom with a walk-through shower, open at both ends, with good pressure and plenty of hot water. The toilets are the old-style gravity kind, and they’re magnificent.

Bedroom with reclaimed timber walls in the Lookout

The beds are very comfortable, and smart thermostats in every room keep the place what we’d call in Wales cwtchy warm. The kitchen has a dishwasher, and a side cupboard holds a washing machine and freezer. There’s also a private hot tub, and after a day exploring Falmouth, it was wonderful.

Eating and drinking

Breakfast was excellent: good Cornish produce, cooked properly, served hot and in sensible portions. “Quality beats quantity every time,” as Jennifer said. The bar is a very easy place to while away an hour, either with a coffee by the fire or a glass of something.

The main restaurant was serving Sunday lunch while we were there, and other guests told us it was excellent, so that’s on the list for next time.

The bar at Merchants Manor

The verdict

The staff were superb, and we couldn’t fault them. The best test of a hotel is whether you want to leave, and on our last morning Jennifer asked if I was ready to go. “No,” I said. “I really like it here.” I could easily have stayed for the winter.

If you’re planning a few days in west Cornwall, Merchants Manor makes a lovely base. As for Landlubber or Lookout, book either. Then go back and try the other one. You’ll find more about our weekend in Falmouth: A Welcome Return, and a closer look at the interiors on Design Life.
Check prices and availability at Merchants Manor

Mark and Jennifer were guests of Falmouth BID.

Merchants Manor
1 Western Terrace, Falmouth TR11 4QJ

01326 312734
info@merchantsmanor.com

www.merchantsmanor.com
…

Where did it all begin?
Our silver wedding stay at Merchants Manor in 2022.
Merchants Manor: A Merchants Tale
…